Independent investigative journalism · AustraliaBylined KCV Media · No paywall · No paid boosting
KCV Media

Veteran Advocacy

The Minister, the Gatekeeper, and the Cap

By KCV Media · Published

Get the next story first

The Minister, the Gatekeeper, and the Cap

IVA, the body DVA built to gatekeep veterans' advocates, is at the centre of two fights hitting Minister Matt Keogh at once.

Jacqui Lambie stood up in the Senate this month and told two federal ministers what she'd like them to imagine. A vaginal prolapse. Surgery to save her bladder. An injury she says is directly linked to her years carrying gear in the army. Then she asked Matt Keogh and Richard Marles what they'd do if the same thing happened to them, and Veterans' Affairs refused to pay for the fix.

That's the temperature of one fight the Minister for Veterans' Affairs is currently losing. He's fighting on two fronts this year, and they're connected by more than just his name on both press releases.

The Department of Veterans' Affairs built a new body to police who gets to represent veterans chasing compensation. Now DVA wants to make that body the only door in. At the same time, the minister who champions it is facing open revolt from the veteran community over a $5,000 cap on the health treatment they can access, and the people running the institute he created have been fighting a very public battle to defend it.

A consultation paper released by DVA in February proposes a rule that would stop advocates from lodging a veteran's DVA claim at all unless they belong to an approved organisation. Under the plan, the Minister for Veterans' Affairs would personally sign off on that organisation's rulebook. The paper doesn't name the organisation outright, but it doesn't have to. There's only one candidate, and DVA built it.

How we got here

The Institute of Veterans' Advocacy exists because Minister Matt Keogh put it there. He announced it personally on 24 February 2025, framing it as a crackdown on "unethical practices of some fee-charging advocates." DVA had already run a 95-submission public consultation and was, in its own words, "working with an interim Board to establish the Institute." RSL Australia backed the announcement the same day, an independent confirmation of both the fact and its framing.

IVA was incorporated five weeks later. The Commonwealth committed $3 million to it over four years, a line item tucked inside a much larger $203.1 million package Keogh has kept front and centre through 2026, most recently doubling annual grants to free veteran advocates in March. By IVA's own account to a Senate inquiry, membership fees alone won't cover its running costs. It has since registered as a deductible-gift-recipient charity to chase tax-deductible donations.

The case for doing something isn't invented. A Senate inquiry heard sworn evidence that one commercial advocacy firm, charging 7 per cent commission on an average $300,000 payout and processing around 300 claims a year, could pull in $6.5 million annually. Nationally, the inquiry was told, the commercial sector could be extracting "tens of millions, potentially more than $100 million a year" from veterans' statutory compensation, several times what DVA spends on free advocacy through its own grants program. Termination fees in excess of $27,000 were reported to the same inquiry. DVA's own officials described commercial operators running "vertically integrated" businesses combining advocacy, medical and diagnostic services under one roof, filing reports the department called "purposely vague, unclear and broad."

No alternative was ever on the table

The Senate committee that examined the sector tabled its report on 4 November 2025. Its central recommendation: DVA should "work closely with" IVA, using the regulator that oversees migration agents as a template. A review of the full report and every submission to it found no genuine alternative to IVA was ever proposed, by the committee, by DVA, or by anyone else. The only accountability check written into the recommendation is a formal review of IVA after two years of operation.

That matters because of who gets to sit on IVA's board, and who gets to vote on who sits there. Under IVA's own constitution, only individual members can vote at general meetings. Ex-service organisations, who join as "Organisational Members," can't. The board itself needs a member representative, someone with ex-service-organisation experience, a veteran, and someone with training experience. None of those categories rules out a commercial fee-for-service operator. A commercial advocate is a veteran too, and can hold "training experience" as easily as anyone else. Nothing in IVA's founding document stops the board looking however its membership base decides it should look.

The warning nobody asked for

RSL Australia, the country's largest ex-service organisation and one of the loudest voices demanding action on commercial advocates, put its own concern in writing to DVA in May: IVA's board could end up captured by the very commercial operators it exists to regulate.

"It is conceivable that it will be governed by a Board with a majority of directors drawn from commercial advocacy services," RSL Australia's submission states, warning of "the spectre of conflicts of interest and perceptions of a commercially captured IVA."

RSL Australia also flagged what it calls the single most serious structural flaw in the plan. Ex-service organisations are effectively forced into IVA membership, because future government grant funding depends on it. Commercial fee-for-service operators face no such pressure. They can simply decline to join IVA and keep operating outside its code of conduct entirely, while paying a flat $2,750 annual fee regardless of how many offices they run nationally. RSL Australia's own 1,087 sub-branches pay $275 each. RSL Australia says it may reconsider its own support for IVA if the roles of accreditation and enforcement aren't kept separate.

IVA's own public messaging confirms the door is open. In a detailed explainer posted to a veterans' Facebook group in March, IVA director Lucinda Casey confirmed that fee-for-service advocates can join, "as long as they agree to the terms and conditions of the constitution and by laws." Commenters pushed back immediately. One asked how a body funded and set up by DVA could ever be truly independent of it. Another raised a scenario where DVA could effectively sideline IVA-accredited medical professionals by simply declining to send them assessments. Neither question drew a public reply from Casey in that thread.

IVA's Chief Executive Officer Alana Scheiffers responded to these concerns when KC VICE put them to her directly. She described RSL Australia's warning as a hypothetical scenario raised during consultation, not evidence of a current problem, and noted the same RSL Australia submission otherwise supported IVA's establishment and its central role in the sector. She said the current interim Board isn't controlled by fee-for-service providers, and pointed to constitutional safeguards: organisational members can't vote, individual members can, and directors face term limits and mandatory rotation, alongside statutory duties to disclose and manage conflicts of interest.

Those safeguards are real. KC VICE checked them directly against IVA's Constitution. Directors serve a maximum of three years per appointment and generally no more than nine years in total, with at least a third of the board required to retire at every AGM. But those provisions guard against one specific risk, a director entrenching themselves indefinitely. They do nothing to prevent the risk RSL Australia actually raised, which is about who gets elected to the board in the first place. Nothing in IVA's constitution stops a commercial fee-for-service operator being elected, repeatedly, by a member-elected board, fully compliant with the rotation rules the entire time. Scheiffers isn't wrong about what she cited. She's answering a different question to the one RSL Australia asked.

This has already happened once

RSL Australia isn't describing a hypothetical. The exact scenario it's warning about already played out, independently of IVA, inside RSL's own New South Wales branch.

Mick Bainbridge, RSL NSW's president from 2023, and fellow board member Paul James co-founded Operational Legal Australia, a commercial fee-for-service veterans' law firm, back in 2019. Both continued sitting on the RSL NSW board while running it. A year-long external investigation found they had failed to disclose representing a client in active legal proceedings against RSL LifeCare, RSL NSW's own sister charity, while sitting on a board making decisions that affected it. Legal advice to RSL NSW found this may have breached their professional obligations as lawyers. Separately, James had secretly drafted a parliamentary bill that would have let RSL NSW seize sub-branch property assets worth tens of millions of dollars without member consent, and kept it from the membership.

Senator Jacqui Lambie filed a 50-page complaint against the firm. Twelve separate complaints went to the NSW Office of the Legal Services Commissioner alleging overcharging, duplicated billing and intimidation of vulnerable veteran clients. Bainbridge, James and two other directors resigned twelve minutes before a scheduled vote to remove them, in October 2025. The Senate committee's own report independently records the same conflict in a footnote, alongside the ABC 7.30 investigation that first exposed it.

Two separate, independent processes reached the same finding. A commercial operator sitting on the board of the organisation meant to hold it accountable is not a theoretical risk. RSL caught and ended it through its own governance process, which cuts both ways. The mechanism that let it happen in the first place is structurally the same one RSL Australia is now warning could happen again, this time inside the body DVA wants to hand gatekeeper powers to.

A chairman's own history

Michael von Berg, IVA's chairman, has his own governance question attached to him, though it's an old one and it isn't the kind of conviction the word usually implies.

In 1996 the Federal Court found von Berg, then a director of The Vales Wine Company, had aided and abetted the company's contravention of the Trade Practices Act. The company had sold bulk wine to major Australian wineries as specific varietals, shiraz and cabernet sauvignon, when it was actually blended wine, roughly doubling the price across sales of between 30,000 and 198,000 litres. It's a thirty-year-old finding from an entirely different industry, decades before IVA existed.

When the finding resurfaced on social media this year, IVA director Casey defended him directly, writing that it involved "findings under the Trade Practices Act concerning misleading and deceptive conduct, not a criminal fraud conviction." Checked against the court record, that's accurate. It was a civil contravention, not what most people mean by fraud, and it's fair to say so plainly rather than let the word "conviction" alone carry more than the finding actually supports.

Whether a decades-old commercial finding, unrelated to veterans at all, bears on von Berg's fitness to chair a veterans' advocacy body is a fair question for IVA's own board and membership to answer, not one this masthead is answering for them. IVA answered it anyway when KC VICE put it to them directly. Scheiffers said the Board considered the nature of the 1996 finding, including that it was a civil contravention rather than a criminal conviction, its age, and von Berg's record of service to the veteran community, and was satisfied he met IVA's requirements for appointment and remained an appropriate person to chair the organisation.

That's IVA's account of its own internal deliberation. KC VICE hasn't sighted board minutes or any documentation of the decision, so it's reported here as IVA's stated position, not as an independently confirmed fact.

It's also worth noting there's no written standard the Board could have applied. None of IVA's governing documents, not the Constitution, the Board Charter, nor the Code of Conduct, set out a fit-and-proper-person test for director or chair appointment. The Constitution's only formal eligibility bar for a director is that they not be ineligible under the Corporations Act or the ACNC Act, a narrow legal-disqualification test rather than a broader character standard. So when IVA says the Board was satisfied von Berg met its requirements, that reflects the Board's own discretionary judgment. There's no documented requirement it can be measured against.

Who's actually allowed to speak for IVA

There's a wrinkle in how IVA has been defending itself in public. The institute's own Board Charter says a director must get the Chair's sign-off before commenting publicly, including on social media, about IVA's business or about DVA, CSC or other ex-service organisations. The Charter is explicit about why: "the Chair or CEO should generally be the spokespeople for the IVA."

Casey has been the most visible defender of IVA and its chairman across multiple public Facebook threads this year, posting explainers, correcting critics, and personally reaching out to at least one prominent critic. Whether each of those posts had the Chair's prior approval, as IVA's own governance rules require, isn't something this masthead can determine from outside the organisation. It's a fair, specific question, and one IVA was given the opportunity to answer.

IVA's answer: the Chair was aware of, and had authorised, Casey's public engagement on IVA-related matters generally. According to Scheiffers, the Board Charter requires the Chair's approval before a director comments publicly, but not sign-off on the wording of each individual post, and IVA's communications arrangements were less formal during its establishment phase, when some of that social media activity took place. IVA has since introduced a dedicated Media Policy and its own organisational social media channels.

Whether a standing authorisation to engage publicly satisfies the Charter's requirement of "prior approval" before publishing "any material" is genuinely open to two readings. Nothing in the Charter itself defines the term precisely enough to settle it either way. IVA's interpretation is plausible. It isn't the only one the text supports.

Not a clean story

This isn't a story with an obvious villain. Luke Armstrong, founder of the rival advocacy group P-VAC and a former commercial operator himself, was criticised at the Senate inquiry over a 9 per cent commission model at his old company. He's also the person who recorded and reported a kickback scheme, in which a telehealth medicinal cannabis company was offering advocates a 5 per cent cut in perpetuity for veteran referrals, to DVA earlier this year. The commercial advocacy sector itself is fracturing over the same question IVA is meant to settle. One industry group's push to ban commission-based fees outright saw its own founding members revolt and split off to form a rival body.

IVA's own newer rulebook deserves the same fairness. Its Professional Standards, approved by the board on 18 August, ban percentage-based and success fees outright, and require advocates to prominently disclose any related-entity or vertically-integrated service arrangement, exactly the kind of "vertically integrated corporate structure" DVA officials complained about to the Senate inquiry. It's real, recent governance work, not just a press release.

The cap and the room he lost

Keogh's other fight this year has been louder and closer to home. The 2026-27 Budget introduced a $5,000 annual limit on what Veteran Card holders can spend on allied health treatment, chiropractic, exercise physiology, physiotherapy, podiatry, psychology, social work, speech therapy and more, starting 1 July 2027. Open Arms counselling is exempt. DVA says it will keep funding treatment above the cap where there's a genuine clinical need, though DVA's own announcement acknowledges the approval mechanism for that isn't finalised yet, and says it's "working to ensure the process is simple." The government is also putting $169.7 million into higher allied-health provider fees from the same date, which it calls the largest such investment in two decades.

None of that has landed. What's landed instead is a minister who spent a fortnight explaining himself over how one meeting with veterans actually went.

The Coalition of Veterans Voices travelled to Canberra on 17 August asking for a sit-down. Keogh's office knocked it back. When the veterans made it known publicly that they'd been refused, the government scrambled and agreed to a meeting that evening.

By most accounts, it went worse than not meeting at all.

Former RAAF pilot Tim Nelson was in the room. His account, on the record: "He walked into the room, refused to shake our hands, sat down with his arms crossed, and rolled his eyes when we started telling him about the effect that this cap already is having on veterans." Keogh reportedly told the group he was frustrated about missing a Governor-General function that evening. John Armfield, a former Navy clearance diver whose brother died by suicide, was also there and separately criticised Keogh for focusing on the "Budget bottom line."

Veteran advocate Julie-Ann Finney, whose son died and who has campaigned publicly on veterans' issues since, was also there. She described the meeting afterward as marked by "dismissive arrogance," and said Keogh is "not and never will be fit to serve." Those are her words and her judgment of him, not an independently verified account of the room, but Nelson's and Armfield's separate, named descriptions line up with hers closely enough that it isn't just one aggrieved person's read of a bad meeting. She also named IVA directly and unprompted in a separate post: "If you need an advocate, make sure they are not affiliated with institute of veterans advocates."

It was in the comments on that second post that Casey reached out to Finney personally, inviting her to bring her concerns to IVA's board directly and noting a personal connection: "I served with your son in HMAS Stuart and here in Canberra and have very fond memories of him."

Keogh has responded to the conduct allegations specifically. In Parliament, he apologised for the part he accepts: "I thank those veterans for meeting with me yesterday afternoon and I acknowledge that I got it wrong in not agreeing to meet with them last week." On the handshake, arms and eye-rolling, he has disputed the veterans' account, insisting he told the group to relax and that he shook hands with everyone before they left.

Assistant Minister to the PM Patrick Gorman also defended Keogh publicly, putting the original refusal down to "a mistake with his diary" that was fixed the same day. Gorman didn't dispute that the meeting itself went badly, only that Keogh's overall record in the portfolio should outweigh it.

Question Time, three days running

The Coalition kept coming after the meeting. On 18 August, Shadow Minister Phillip Thompson called the cap a "cruel cut" in Question Time and demanded it be scrapped. Keogh held his ground, describing the change as a shift from constant referrals to a threshold with an exceptions process for higher clinical need, and promised a discussion paper.

By 20 August, Thompson had gone further, relaying a line in Parliament he attributed to an unnamed veteran who'd served multiple combat tours in Afghanistan: "I think I prefer to deal with the Taliban. That was much more simple." Thompson then asked the Prime Minister directly when he'd sack his Veterans' Affairs Minister.

Nationals leader Michael McCormack had already landed a cleaner hit a few days earlier, challenging Keogh to name a single veterans' group that actually supported the cap. He couldn't.

The party isn't unified either

The pressure isn't only coming from the Coalition. Reporting on internal Labor sentiment describes real division over whether Keogh should stay in the job. One Labor MP, speaking anonymously: "He's worked hard to reverse lots of the problems we inherited in Vets Affairs from the Coalition, but I think the past week has shown it might be time for him to do something else." Another anonymous Labor figure claims Keogh has told colleagues privately he'd prefer a different frontbench role, but that Albanese wants him to stay put. Gorman's public position was firmer: "Matt Keogh does not need to do [switch portfolios]," pointing to his record delivering Royal Commission recommendations and securing extra departmental staff.

None of that is confirmed beyond the reporting itself, unnamed sources describing internal party mood are exactly that, but it's consistent with a minister who spent three straight days being hit in Parliament and then had his own colleague publicly deny that a portfolio change was on the table, which is usually the kind of thing you only need to deny if someone's asked.

The exemption doing the heaviest lifting

If the cap is going to work the way DVA says it will, Open Arms is the release valve. It's the one service the $5,000 threshold doesn't touch, which means every veteran who hits the cap on physio, psychology or the rest has a reason to lean on it harder.

Open Arms has already needed help meeting demand as it stands. It runs a formal agreement with Bupa to place additional counsellors into regions with extended wait times, covering the country except North Queensland. That arrangement predates the cap entirely, it exists because Open Arms couldn't meet demand on its own in parts of the country before this policy gave veterans a fresh reason to use it more.

Nobody in the public debate over the cap, not DVA, not Keogh, not the Coalition attacking him, has said anything about whether Open Arms can absorb the extra load an exemption this significant is likely to create. It's the quietest part of a very loud fight.

What we don't know yet

DVA's consultation on the gatekeeper proposal closed in May. As of this month, no outcome report has been published, well past the roughly four-month turnaround the department managed after its 2024 consultation on establishing IVA itself. Whether individual submissions will be made public, as they were last time, is unclear.

IVA's first financial disclosure isn't due until later this year at the earliest, so there's no independent picture yet of how much of its money comes from government grants versus membership fees versus donations. A parallel DVA project to create a separate national body representing ex-service organisations is due to report soon. It's a different function to IVA's, individual advocate regulation versus organisational representation, but it fits a pattern. Identify a Royal Commission recommendation, stand up a preferred vehicle, fund it, and work out the governance later.

A pattern, laid out plainly

KC VICE emailed Minister Keogh's office on 30 August 2026 with specific questions about the matters raised in this article, and a stated deadline of close of business Monday 7 September. That deadline passed without a response of any kind.

KC VICE also emailed the Institute of Veterans' Advocacy on 30 August 2026. Chief Executive Officer Alana Scheiffers responded within 24 hours, addressing RSL Australia's board-capture concerns. KC VICE wrote again the same day, asking IVA to also address Michael von Berg's 1996 Federal Court finding and whether Lucinda Casey's public defence of IVA and its chairman had the Board Chair's prior approval as IVA's own Board Charter requires. Scheiffers answered both questions on 7 September, within the original deadline, her responses reflected in the sections above.

Both parties were told in writing, at the time of the original request, that a non-response would be reported alongside the dates of the request. This is that record. No further extension was offered to either party beyond the original deadline.

The meeting-conduct claims and the wider political fallout from the allied-health cap are already public record, independently reported by multiple outlets before this article, and Keogh's own response to those specific allegations is included above where they're discussed. No separate Right of Reply request was made on those matters.

Correction, 8 October 2026: An earlier version of this article said the commercial advocacy firm in the Senate inquiry evidence charged 9 per cent commission. The evidence described a 7 per cent commission. The $6.5 million figure was correct.

Get the next story first

One email when a new story goes live. Nothing else. Unsubscribe any time.

We only use your email to send you new stories. We never share or sell it. See our Privacy Policy.

From KCV Publishing

Books from KCV Media's own publishing arm.

You're Not Broken, You're Overloaded coverYou're Not Broken, You're Overloaded The Algorithm coverThe Algorithm The Scenic Rim coverThe Scenic Rim The Genesis Code coverThe Genesis Code

See all books →