Investigations
Cleanaway Wants Bromelton. Here's the Record.
By KCV Media · Published
Cleanaway wants to build a waste-to-energy plant at Bromelton that's designed to burn about 760,000 tonnes of waste a year, with capacity for up to 836,000. The application is with Queensland's Coordinator-General, and public submissions close on 16 November.
Big projects get judged on promises. Emissions controls, water management, safety systems. Cleanaway's made all of those. But there's another record worth reading first, and it's not one the company wrote. It's the one written by judges, magistrates and regulators across five states over the past twelve years.
We went through it. Here's what it shows.
Two dead on the South Eastern Freeway
On 18 August 2014 a loaded Cleanaway vacuum truck ran down the South Eastern Freeway into Adelaide and hit three cars at the Cross Road intersection. Jacqueline Byrne and Thomas Spiess were killed. The truck driver lost a leg and broke his neck. Another driver suffered a fractured neck and back.
It was the driver's first week in the job. Comcare's investigation found he'd been trained only on relatively flat roads in a truck with an automatic transmission. That day he was driving a manual heavy vehicle for the first time, down the steep Adelaide Hills descent.
Charges were laid against Cleanaway Operations Pty Ltd in 2016. The company fought them. It lost at trial. On appeal, six of the eight charges were thrown out as duplicates, but the convictions on the other two stood. It lost again at the South Australian Court of Appeal in October 2025, and the High Court refused to hear it, saying there was "no reason to doubt" the Court of Appeal's decision.
On 28 May 2026 the company was fined $1.1 million. It's the largest penalty ever imposed under federal work safety law.
The sentencing judge, Auxiliary Justice Chris Kourakis, a former Chief Justice of South Australia, didn't stop at the fine. He said contesting the charges "showed a lack of insight by Cleanaway and a superficial understanding of its obligations." He found the company had failed "to acknowledge the critical failures which exposed so many to the risk of serious injury or death."
Cleanaway argued the long delay should count in its favour. The judge said much of that delay "was the result of Cleanaway's unmeritorious denial of its culpability," and that whatever burden it caused the company "pales into insignificance in comparison to the anguish the delay has caused the victims of its offending."
He also gave the company some credit. AAP reported that the judge reduced the penalty because of Cleanaway's "significant systemic safeguarding" since the crash.
Nearly twelve years from crash to sentence.
Queensland: the smell over Ipswich
In February 2022 heavy rain pooled in a landfill cell at Cleanaway's New Chum site near Ipswich. The water mixed with waste, fermented and started giving off hydrogen sulphide. Rotten egg gas. It hung over homes for months.
In March 2023 the state's environment department charged Cleanaway Solid Waste Pty Ltd with 12 offences. One of them was wilfully causing an environmental nuisance.
In November 2024 the company pleaded guilty to seven offences in Ipswich Magistrates Court. The reports we've seen don't say which seven. It was fined more than $600,000, reported as the biggest odour nuisance penalty Queensland's regulator has ever secured.
According to press reports of the sentencing, the court found Cleanaway failed to take all reasonable and practicable measures to stop the smell. It also found the company pumped contaminated water around the site and used it for dust suppression.
Cleanaway told the ABC it acknowledged the impact on the community and had since spent more than $60 million on the site, including stormwater management and gas capture.
It's the closest case to home. Same state, same kind of problem, water and waste and the people living next door.
NSW: kerosene in the Molonglo
On 14 May 2020 valves failed at Cleanaway's Queanbeyan premises and 2,500 litres of kerosene solvent went into the stormwater system and the Molonglo River.
The NSW EPA says the company knew about it at around midday. It didn't tell the EPA until 5pm.
The next day the polluted water was pumped out of the river and taken back to the site. Then 1,500 litres of it escaped again. Same valve failures.
In April 2022 the Land and Environment Court convicted Cleanaway Equipment Services Pty Ltd of two water pollution offences and one of failing to notify. Fines totalled $617,500, plus $110,778 in EPA investigation costs and legal costs. The court also ordered the company to publicise its offences.
NSW: fire at St Marys
On 19 April 2022 flammable gas escaped from a machine crushing aerosol cans and paint tins at Cleanaway's liquid waste plant in St Marys, in Sydney's west. A spark from an electric motor that had no guard set it alight. A worker suffered severe burns to his face and hands. It took more than 130 firefighters several hours to bring the fire under control.
Comcare's then CEO, Greg Vines, said workers had raised safety concerns before the fire, including gas escaping from the machine as recently as five days earlier. Expert evidence showed the motor and the machine didn't comply with industry standards and regulatory requirements for electrical installations.
In February 2025 Cleanaway Operations Pty Ltd pleaded guilty in Sydney's Downing Centre Local Court. It was convicted and fined $300,000.
Victoria: stockpiles and exposed waste
After two small fires at Cleanaway's Brooklyn facility in early 2021, EPA Victoria officers found waste stockpiles that were too high and too close together. The company had also missed EPA deadlines for fire risk plans. Convicted in July 2023, fined $15,000 plus $7,344 costs.
In February 2023, EPA officers at the Stawell landfill found a strong odour beyond the boundary, a large area of exposed waste, poorly compacted waste and degraded cover. Convicted in April 2024, fined $25,000 plus $15,000 costs, and an adverse publicity order.
WA: the wrong cover
At Dardanup in 2019, WA's environment department found drill muds stored incorrectly and shredder floc used as cover material. Cleanaway pleaded guilty in November 2020 and was fined $25,000. The department told the court an experienced waste company "should have been aware of its legal responsibilities under its licence."
Before the courts
Lucas Heights. A case involving Cleanaway's Lucas Heights site in Sydney is currently before the courts. We can't report on it while the case is under way.
The levy
In May 2026 the Victorian Supreme Court ruled that crushed rock from a neighbouring quarry, which Cleanaway's Melbourne Regional Landfill operator used as daily cover, was waste, and that the levy should've been paid on it. The court put the 2017-18 underpayment at $6,936,892.05.
EPA audits allege a further $4.7 million for 2018-19 and $7.2 million for 2021-22. Those amounts haven't been decided by a court. Cleanaway is appealing and has set aside $27.5 million to cover all three years plus costs and interest.
Still running
Wages. Cleanaway's 2026 annual report says it found enterprise agreement non-compliance in northern NSW, paid affected staff and spent $5.7 million on the review and compensation. It's set aside another $9 million for similar problems under other agreements. It says the full review is still going.
Deaths. By its own annual reports, Cleanaway recorded three fatalities within its operational control in 2024-25. In 2025-26 a contract driver died at its Coolaroo recycling facility in Melbourne, and a customer's worker died at Melbourne Regional Landfill. No court has made any finding about these deaths.
What Cleanaway says about itself
This needs to be in here too.
After the deaths, Cleanaway's board commissioned an independent review of its safety strategy. The company says the review found "no evidence of a systemic failure in strategy design, governance or organisational commitment to safety," though it found room to improve consistency at the frontline. The board accepted the recommendations. The review itself hasn't been published.
The company reports its serious and recordable injury rates improved in 2025-26, says it had no significant environmental incidents that year, and says executives lost the safety part of their bonus because of the Coolaroo death.
Cleanaway runs more than 350 sites with over 10,000 people. A company that size will have incidents. Nobody's claiming every Cleanaway site is badly run.
A new owner
Cleanaway may not own itself for much longer.
On 19 October 2026, Swedish private equity group EQT announced a binding agreement for its fund EQT Infrastructure VI to buy 100% of Cleanaway. Shareholders would get $3.095 cash a share, less any dividends paid or declared before the deal completes. EQT puts the enterprise value at about $9.3 billion.
Cleanaway's board unanimously recommends the deal, as long as no better offer turns up and an independent expert finds it's in shareholders' best interests. It still needs a shareholder vote, Federal Court approval and regulatory approvals. EQT expects it to be done by the end of March 2027.
EQT says it plans to work with Cleanaway's management and staff and to invest in the infrastructure Australia's waste and recycling needs. EQT's 19 October announcement doesn't mention Bromelton, energy from waste or safety.
EQT isn't new to burning waste for energy. In 2021 it took US operator Covanta private in a deal worth about US$5.3 billion including debt. That business, now called Reworld, owns or operates more than 90 facilities across North America, according to EQT. EQT also owns Encyclis, an energy-from-waste operator in the UK and Ireland.
The question for Bromelton
This section is KCV Media's analysis, not reported fact.
Take the cases one at a time and each looks like a local failure. Put them side by side and it's a different picture.
A new driver sent down a steep descent without the right training. Valves that failed twice in two days. A five-hour wait to tell the regulator. Stockpiles stacked against the rules. Waste left uncovered. Shredder floc used as landfill cover. Contaminated water pumped around a site and used for dust suppression. Missed deadlines. None of this is cutting-edge engineering. It's the daily running of a waste business, and courts in five states found the company got it wrong.
Bromelton isn't a landfill or a truck route. It's a waste-burning plant designed to handle about 760,000 tonnes a year, with capacity for up to 836,000, built on promises about emissions control, water containment and heavy vehicle movements. Water getting out where it shouldn't, smell getting over the fence and heavy vehicles around people are three of the areas where the court record shows things going wrong.
So here's the question. On the court findings above, if basic site management has broken down this often, at this many sites, over this many years, why should Queensland accept that a far more complex plant will be run any better?
And if the takeover goes through, the company asking for that trust will pass to a new owner that has made no public statement about Bromelton.
It's not a question the courts can answer. It's one for Cleanaway, for EQT if its deal goes ahead, and for the Coordinator-General deciding whether to approve Bromelton.
Right of reply
We sent Cleanaway written questions on Thursday 15 October 2026 and asked for a response by 5pm AEST on Thursday 22 October, five business days. We told the company that if we didn't hear back by then, the article would say so.
Cleanaway did reply the same day, but only to ask questions of its own: who KCV Media is, and whether we're a member of the Australian Press Council. We answered on 16 October. We're an independent outlet, we're not a Press Council member, and the deadline still stood.
Cleanaway didn't answer any of our questions by the deadline.
Disclosure: KCV Media founder Ken (KC) Chancellor lives in the Scenic Rim, has publicly opposed BERC, and stood as a candidate for Scenic Rim Regional Council.
Sources
- Commonwealth DPP, Record penalty for devastating truck crash, 2026
- Comcare, Record WHS penalty over fatal truck crash, 28 May 2026
- AAP, Company fined $1.1m over deadly sewage truck crash, May 2026
- Queensland Government, Past programs: Cleanaway New Chum 2022
- ABC News, 27 November 2024, New Chum sentencing
- Local Ipswich News, New Chum sentencing report, December 2024
- NSW EPA Annual Report 2021-22, page 95
- Comcare, Company fined over Sydney fire, injuries, 7 February 2025
- EPA Victoria prosecution records, Brooklyn and Stawell
- WA Government, Cleanaway fined $25,000 for environmental breaches, 5 November 2020
- EPA Victoria, Supreme Court upholds EPA Victoria's Landfill Levy argument, 11 May 2026
- Cleanaway ASX announcement, 7 May 2026, and FY25 and FY26 annual reports
- Cleanaway newsroom, Fatal incident at Melbourne Regional Landfill, 18 December 2025
- EQT, EQT agrees to acquire Cleanaway, press release, 19 October 2026 (eqtgroup.com)
- Cleanaway, Cleanaway enters into Scheme Implementation Deed with EQT Infrastructure, ASX and media release, 19 October 2026
- EQT, EQT Infrastructure to acquire Covanta Holding Corporation, press release, 14 July 2021
- EQT current portfolio pages, Reworld and Encyclis
- Cleanaway, BERC application, Appendix E Technical Process Description, Revision D, page 6
- Office of the Coordinator-General, Bromelton SDA application consultation page (open 1 October to 16 November 2026)
Related: Seven Questions, No Answers: Where Does Jon Krause Stand on BERC?
Get the next story first
One email when a new story goes live. Nothing else. Unsubscribe any time.
We only use your email to send you new stories. We never share or sell it. See our Privacy Policy.




